Gates (Hugh McLean) shows up one morning with what seems to be a split personality and includes some very bad news that shakes the cast.
Jamie (Josh Gaffga) shows up one morning wearing earrings and this causes a big problem for Gates (Hugh McLean). He won't act in the show if Jamie wears them, which in turn, creates a major problem for Rudy (Jack Kelly) to deal with.
The cast finds out that Kelly (Johanna Jowett) wrote a song in college but wonder why she is so reluctant to play it for them.