When Veronica's horse, Cobalt, returns to camp riderless, the Saddle Club, together with Phil, put themselves in danger to rescue Veronica.
When Phil and his Pony Club come to Pine Hollow to participate in a mystery weekend to raise funds, they discover there is a real thief in their midst and the Saddle Club set out to catch the culprit.
Max reversed his decision to sell Prancer after the horse saves the girls from certain death by killing a poisonous snake.