Trapped at Pine Hollow due to flash flooding, the students are forced to endure a sleepover. When Desi goes hyper after she thinks she’s eaten paprika, she takes delight in telling everyone how it really is.
Stevie and Lisa have an argument on the Saddle Club Anniversary, it looks like the group could be splitting up. It is up to Carole to make the girls look beyond their differences and remember their love of horses, in order to save their friendship.
As part of their final assessment, the Pine Hollow students take part in an overnight endurance ride. But when the group start bickering and Garnet goes missing, the students must use their survival skills and teamwork to find the horse.
After Carole is selected for a scholarship at a prestigious international riding academy, the Saddle Club must host a musical fundraiser, so Carole and Starlight can afford to travel overseas and take part in the opportunity of a lifetime.