Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
105 - Simply Vanished
Season 1, Episode 5
•
Drama, Western, Mystery, TV-PG
TV-PG. As her birthday nears, Cheryl Cooper reflects on the life she’s built in Sugarcreek—until she discovers a hidden laundry chute in the Swiss Miss Gift Shop tied to a woman who vanished decades ago. While her family visit stirs unresolved tensions, Cheryl uncovers buried secrets and long-held pain. Her search for truth brings closure, healing, and a deeper sense of belonging.
UP Next - "Stitch in Time" on 5/21!
Up Next in Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Season 1
-
106 - Stitch in Time
TV-PG. When a mysterious quilt surfaces at an estate sale, Cheryl Cooper and Naomi Miller uncover a decades-old secret tied to a lost Amish daughter and a hidden adoption. As tensions rise with a determined suitor and buried family wounds resurface, Cheryl follows the quilt’s clues to reunite gen...
-
107 - Mason Jar Mayhem
TV-PG. When mason jars filled with WWII-era coins and letters are uncovered in a historic farmhouse, Cheryl Cooper helps Sugarcreek unravel a wartime secret tied to faith, sacrifice, and a fractured family. But when the treasure vanishes, suspicion spreads. As Cheryl follows clues through buried ...
-
Season 1 Finale: 108 - When There's a...
TV-PG. When a beloved uncle’s death puts Levi Miller’s farmland at risk of becoming a prison, Cheryl Cooper races against time to find a missing deed erased by county corruption. With faith, persistence, and community on her side, Cheryl uncovers hidden wills, digital sabotage, and long-buried tr...
