Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
103 - O Little Town of Sugarcreek
Season 1, Episode 3
•
Drama, Western, Mystery, TV-PG
TV-PG. As Christmas approaches in Sugarcreek, Cheryl Cooper’s peaceful holiday plans unravel when her ex-fiancé returns with a surprising proposal and a series of thefts shakes the town. When suspicion falls on her close friend Levi Miller, Cheryl must uncover the truth before mistrust ruins the season. Balancing faith, forgiveness, and unresolved love, Cheryl fights to restore justice—and the town’s Christmas spirit.
Up Next in Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Season 1
-
104 - Off the Beaten Path
TV-PG-L. As winter settles over Sugarcreek, Cheryl Cooper plans a Valentine’s-themed event that brings the town together—and stirs her hidden feelings for Levi Miller. But the weekend turns dangerous when a tour bus vanishes and a mysterious woman draws the attention of impostor FBI agents. Teami...
-
105 - Simply Vanished
TV-PG. As her birthday nears, Cheryl Cooper reflects on the life she’s built in Sugarcreek—until she discovers a hidden laundry chute in the Swiss Miss Gift Shop tied to a woman who vanished decades ago. While her family visit stirs unresolved tensions, Cheryl uncovers buried secrets and long-hel...
-
106 - Stitch in Time
TV-PG. When a mysterious quilt surfaces at an estate sale, Cheryl Cooper and Naomi Miller uncover a decades-old secret tied to a lost Amish daughter and a hidden adoption. As tensions rise with a determined suitor and buried family wounds resurface, Cheryl follows the quilt’s clues to reunite gen...
